La titularidad de los derechos patrimoniales de esta obra pertenece a las instituciones editoras. Su uso se rige por una licencia Creative Commons BY 4.0 Internacional, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode.es, para un uso diferente consultar al responsable jurídico del repositorio por medio del correo electrónico bmdc.iij@unam.mx.
Ver términos de la licenciaHarris Moya, Pedro (2024). El recurso indirecto en el contencioso-administrativo español y francés: entre legalidad y seguridad. Boletín Mexicano de Derecho Comparado; nueva época, volumen 57, número 171, septiembre-diciembre de 2024; 187-209. Recuperado de https://repositorio.unam.mx/contenidos/4161269
Autor(es)
Harris Moya, Pedro
Tipo
Artículo de Investigación
Área del conocimiento
Ciencias Sociales y Económicas
Título
El recurso indirecto en el contencioso-administrativo español y francés: entre legalidad y seguridad
Fecha
2024-12-11
Resumen
This paper aims to compare how indirect claims have articulated the principles of legal security and the rule of law in French and Spanish administrative law, through the dogmatic method. The first part of this research analyzes the control perspective. By not conditioning the claim to an existing regulation and adopting a broader understanding of the incurred defects, this research concludes that French Law prioritizes legal control. In contrast, Spain emphasizes security due to a more rigorous examination of the acts and their irregularities. The second part of this article studies the sanction applicable once the illegality is verified. By extending the jurisdictional competence (which would encompass non-specialised tribunals) and establishing mechanisms to annul the disregarded acts, it is plausible to assert that Spain prioritises legality. In France, this perspective is reversed in favour of security because of a strict understanding of that competence and the absence of nullifying mechanisms.
These differences allow us to conclude the existence of different variants of indirect claims, a useful circumstance at a comparative level, especially in regulations lacking a consolidated interpretation in the exercise of these claims.
Tema
contencioso-administrativo; acciones administrativas; administrative litigation; administrative claims; indirect claims
Idioma
spa
ISSN
ISSN electrónico: 2448-4873; ISSN impreso: 0041-8633
